Tier 1
- , since .
- , since .
- .
- . They are orders of magnitude apart.
- times more intense.
- Amplitude ratio: times larger.
- .
- times greater.
Tier 2
- (a) Amplitude ratio: times. (b) Energy ratio: times.
- Difference: dB. Intensity ratio: times more intense.
- The values span orders of magnitude ( to ). On a linear scale, and would be indistinguishable near the axis while dominates. A log scale spaces all five points evenly, revealing the constant factor-of- pattern.
- Coffee is more acidic (lower pH). Concentration ratio: times more hydrogen ions in the coffee.
- After years (5 doublings): . On a log scale, exponential growth (constant doubling time) appears as a straight line because , which is linear in .
- Ratio .
Tier 3
- is undefined because there is no power such that (powers of are always positive). On a log-scale graph, zero cannot be plotted — the axis extends toward in log-space as values approach zero. This means log scales can only represent strictly positive data.
- Each magnitude step is a factor of . Over steps: . A magnitude- star is about times brighter than a magnitude- star.
- The Richter scale is logarithmic, not linear. A magnitude quake has times the wave amplitude of a magnitude quake — not times. The student confused additive and multiplicative differences.
- Example table (masses): electron kg, grain of sand kg, human kg, Earth kg, Sun kg. These span about orders of magnitude. A log scale is essential because a linear axis from to would make all but the largest value invisible.
Challenge
- For : , so J. For : , so J. Ratio: (since ). Confirmed.
- Each source has intensity . Combined intensity . Combined level dB. Doubling intensity adds about dB, not dB.
- (a) orders of magnitude. (b) A straight line, because increases linearly with time for exponential growth. (c) Total growth factor over hours. Hourly factor .
- If increases by a factor of , then increases by . So increases by units.